22. Toyota’s Leadership in the Hybrid Vehicle Market: Strategies, Innovations, and Global Success

J. Struben (2006) highlights the past failures of electric vehicles in the 19th century and uses this history to construct a model with two primary technologies: the Internal Combustion Engine (ICE) and Alternative Fuel Vehicles (AFV), which includes hybrids, natural gas vehicles, and hydrogen fuel cell vehicles. The first hybrid vehicle, a combination of gasoline and electric power, was developed in 1901 by Porsche and Lohner, marking a significant step forward in the development of green technology.

However, hybrid vehicles did not gain widespread popularity until the release of the Toyota Prius in Japan in 1997, followed by the Honda Insight in 1999. These vehicles, powered by a combination of traditional gasoline engines and electric motors, paved the way for the mainstream acceptance of hybrid cars.

Their introduction represented a major shift in the automotive industry, as consumers began to seek more fuel-efficient and environmentally friendly options, leading to the growth of hybrid technology in the global car market. The success of these early hybrid models demonstrated the potential of combining traditional internal combustion engines with electric propulsion, setting the stage for the future development of alternative fuel vehicles such as natural gas-powered and hydrogen fuel cell vehicles, as well as fully electric vehicles. Despite the challenges faced by electric vehicles in the past, advancements in battery technology and a growing demand for sustainable transportation options have now positioned electric vehicles as a viable and increasingly popular choice in the automotive industry.

Challenges of eco-friendly cars

Adopting eco-friendly vehicles has proven to be a challenging task due to a variety of factors (Kaplan, 2000). However, significant research has been conducted to explore the reasons behind the adoption of petrol-electric hybrid cars, with several key motivations identified for consumers:

1. Environmental Protection – Concerns regarding global warming and limited oil reserves have driven interest in hybrid vehicles (A.P. Minton, 1997). The ecological consciousness of consumers or environmentally aware individuals leads to a higher likelihood of adopting eco-friendly cars (B. Gatersleben, 2002). As people become increasingly aware of environmental issues, they are more inclined to choose alternatives that help reduce carbon emissions and reliance on fossil fuels.
2. Intrinsic Motives – Some consumers are intrinsically motivated by the desire to purchase pro-environmental products (J. Jansson A. M., 2009). These individuals prioritize the environmental benefits of their purchases and are driven by personal values, such as sustainability and reducing their carbon footprint (A. Diekmann, 1998). Surveys have shown that while the number of consumers with strong environmental values may be limited, they often exhibit a high level of commitment to eco-friendly products (S. Bamberg, 2003).
3. Extrinsic Motives – In contrast, extrinsic factors such as popularity, status, and image play a significant role in motivating consumers to purchase eco-friendly products (J. Jansson, 2009). The social perception of owning a hybrid vehicle as an environmentally responsible and progressive choice can influence decision-making, as some consumers view eco-friendly products as symbols of prestige and modernity.
4. Fuel Consumption – For some individuals, fuel consumption and environmental impact are secondary considerations. These consumers may prioritize other factors, such as vehicle performance or initial cost, over the long-term fuel efficiency or environmental benefits of hybrid cars (J. Jansson, 2009).
5. Consumer’s Decision-Making Process – When considering a car purchase, consumers typically weigh various factors, including budget, performance, lifestyle preferences, social influences, and fuel consumption (V. Griskevicius, 2010). While environmental concerns may influence some buyers, other practical aspects, such as cost-effectiveness and vehicle performance, are often more pressing.

Despite these motivations, the widespread adoption of hybrid cars has been hindered by the complexities and costs associated with the technology. Hybrid vehicles combine both electric and fuel-driven engines, which can lead to higher production costs and potential technical challenges. Additionally, while hybrid cars are marketed as environmentally friendly, they still produce contaminants and are not entirely free of environmental impact (Ashley, 2006). The combination of these factors, alongside competition from established vehicle technologies, makes it challenging to predict the share of hybrid vehicles in advanced countries. The transition to hybrid cars faces significant hurdles as both consumers and manufacturers continue to navigate the complexities of the evolving automotive landscape.

Key benefits of adopting hybrid electric vehicles (HEVs)

Consumers often make car purchase decisions based on the economy of fuel consumption, and hybrid electric vehicles (HEVs) offer a compelling value proposition in this regard. While the initial purchase price of an HEV may be higher than that of a conventional vehicle, the long-term fuel savings make the investment worthwhile. The greater fuel efficiency of HEVs, combined with incentives and other advantages, has helped them gain popularity, especially in markets like the USA. Teske (2006) highlights several key benefits of adopting HEVs:

1. Tax Benefits – In the USA, buyers of HEVs are often eligible for tax incentives, which help offset the higher initial purchase price of these vehicles. These tax credits can significantly reduce the effective cost of purchasing a hybrid, making them more financially attractive to consumers. This policy is a form of government support to encourage the adoption of environmentally friendly vehicles and reduce dependence on fossil fuels.
2. Resale Value – Although HEVs may initially be priced higher than conventional vehicles, their resale value tends to be relatively strong. As the demand for fuel-efficient vehicles continues to rise, used hybrid cars maintain a higher resale price compared to their non-hybrid counterparts. This is especially true for well-maintained models with a proven track record of reliability and fuel savings, making the total cost of ownership for consumers more attractive.
3. Lower Maintenance and Repair Costs – HEVs typically have lower maintenance and repair costs compared to traditional internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles. Hybrid vehicles often require fewer repairs because they have fewer moving parts, and their regenerative braking systems reduce the wear and tear on traditional brake components. Additionally, hybrid engines are generally designed to be more efficient, which can lead to fewer engine-related issues over time. This results in lower ongoing maintenance expenses for owners, making them a more economical choice in the long run.
4. Social Responsibility and Status – Driving a hybrid car in the USA can signal to others that the driver is socially responsible and environmentally conscious. Many consumers purchase HEVs not only for their fuel efficiency and cost savings but also because they align with their values of sustainability and reducing their carbon footprint. Hybrid vehicles are often associated with being “green” and eco-friendly, which can be an important consideration for individuals who wish to demonstrate their commitment to environmental protection. In some cases, owning a hybrid vehicle can also serve as a status symbol, reflecting a modern, progressive lifestyle.

Overall, the adoption of HEVs offers a combination of practical financial benefits and social advantages. The tax incentives, long-term savings on fuel and maintenance, and the growing demand for eco-friendly products have all contributed to the rise in popularity of hybrid vehicles. While there are still challenges associated with their adoption, such as the higher upfront cost and limited infrastructure for charging hybrid-electric models, the advantages continue to make them an appealing option for environmentally conscious consumers.

Teske (2007) highlights Toyota’s dominant position in the hybrid electric vehicle (HEV) market as the pioneer of this technology. The company has been able to leverage several strategies that allow it to maintain a competitive edge and benefit from economies of scale:

1. Introducing New Models – Toyota has been able to expand its reach within the hybrid vehicle market by introducing new models within its hybrid series, such as the Prius family. These models cater to a variety of consumer preferences, from compact to larger vehicles, increasing the brand’s appeal across different market segments. By continually updating and refining its hybrid lineup, Toyota ensures that it remains relevant to consumers looking for eco-friendly alternatives without compromising on style or functionality.
2. Technology and Cost Sharing – In its pursuit of advancing HEV technology, Toyota has engaged in strategic partnerships with other automakers, including sharing technology and research and development (R&D) resources. By collaborating with competitors like Nissan and General Motors (GM), Toyota can collectively benefit from cost-sharing in the development of next-generation hybrid and electric vehicles. This helps to reduce the high upfront costs of R&D and accelerates the pace of innovation in the hybrid space. In addition, these partnerships enable Toyota to stay ahead in terms of technological advancements, such as improvements in battery efficiency, vehicle range, and fuel economy.
3. Sharing Technology with Competitors – Toyota’s willingness to share hybrid technology with competitors is another key aspect of its strategy. By licensing its hybrid technology to other major automakers, Toyota creates a broader ecosystem of hybrid vehicles in the market. This not only promotes the widespread adoption of hybrid technology but also positions Toyota as a leader in the green vehicle movement, even as competitors benefit from its innovations. This strategy can help drive down production costs for all companies involved, fostering a competitive and dynamic hybrid vehicle market.
4. Reducing Production Costs – Toyota has actively worked on reducing production costs to make hybrid vehicles more affordable. According to Shimbun (2005), Toyota is focusing on streamlining its manufacturing processes and improving the efficiency of its supply chain. By lowering the cost of producing hybrid vehicles, Toyota can make these environmentally friendly cars more accessible to a larger consumer base, ultimately driving higher sales volumes. This will also help the company maintain profitability despite the higher upfront costs of hybrid technology.
5. Competition with Honda – While Toyota is the market leader, Honda is a strong competitor, particularly in the hybrid vehicle space. Honda’s hybrid offerings, such as the Honda Insight, are direct competitors to Toyota’s Prius. The rivalry between these two companies has driven significant advancements in hybrid technology, with both companies competing to offer consumers the most fuel-efficient, cost-effective, and technologically advanced vehicles. Honda’s commitment to hybrid technology and its continuous improvements to models like the Honda Civic Hybrid and Honda Accord Hybrid keep it firmly positioned as a major player in the industry.
6. Global Hybrid Sales Leadership – As of September 2014, Toyota’s Prius family has been the top-selling hybrid globally, cementing Toyota’s position as the leader in hybrid vehicle sales (Toyota Is Global Hybrid Leader With Sales of 7 Million, 2014). The Prius has become synonymous with hybrid technology, with its sales outpacing those of other hybrid models worldwide. This success has helped Toyota to set the pace for the hybrid market, influencing both consumer expectations and industry trends.
7. Government Incentives – Government support plays a crucial role in the adoption of hybrid vehicles. In Japan, the government introduced incentives programs and tax benefits aimed at promoting low-emission vehicles, including hybrids (AP, 2010). These policies make hybrid vehicles more affordable for consumers and stimulate demand for environmentally friendly cars. Similarly, in the United States, various federal and state-level incentives have contributed to the increased sales of hybrids. The combination of government support and Toyota’s market leadership has been a driving force in the global adoption of hybrid vehicles.
8. Toyota Aqua’s Success – Following the Prius, the Toyota Aqua has become the second-largest selling hybrid in Japan (Bekker, 2013). The Aqua, known as the Toyota Prius C in some markets, has garnered significant popularity due to its compact size, affordability, and fuel efficiency. Its success in the domestic Japanese market reflects the growing demand for small, fuel-efficient vehicles in urban areas, where consumers are increasingly seeking alternatives to traditional gasoline-powered cars.

In conclusion, Toyota’s dominance in the hybrid market is built on a combination of technological innovation, strategic collaborations, and cost-cutting measures. By sharing its hybrid technology with other automakers, reducing production costs, and continually improving its vehicle offerings, Toyota has cemented its position as the global leader in hybrid vehicle sales. Additionally, government incentives and consumer demand for eco-friendly vehicles have further boosted Toyota’s success in the hybrid market.

Bibliography

A. Diekmann, P. P. (1998). Environmental behavior: Discrepancies between aspirations and reality. ,. Rationality and Society 10 (1), 79-102.

A.P. Minton, R. R. (1997). The effects of environmental concern on environmentally friendly consumer behavior: an exploratory study., . Journal of Business Research 40 (1), 37-48.

AP. (2010, January 8). Prius No. 1 in Japan sales as green interest grows. Retrieved from Drive On: http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/autos/2010-01-08-prius-tops_N.htm

Ashley, S. (2006, August 27). Fuel Cells start to look real. Retrieved from Automotive Engineering International Online: http://southernnewengland.sae.org/automag/ features/ fuel cells/

B. Gatersleben, L. S. (2002). Measurement and determinants of environmentally significant consumer behavior. ,. Environment and Behavior 34 (3), 335-362.

Bekker, H. (2013, January 10). 2012 (Full Year) Japan: Best-Selling Car Models. Retrieved from Car Sales Statistics: http://www.best-selling-cars.com/japan/2012-full-year-japan-best-selling-car-models/

J. Jansson, A. M. (2009). Elucidating green consumers: a cluster analytic approach on proenvironmental purchase and curtailment behaviors. . Journal of Euromarketing 18 (4), , 245 – 267.

J. Struben, J. (2006, August 30). Transition Challenegs for Alternative Fuel Vehicle and Transportation systems . MIT Sloan School of Management, Engineering System Division, ESD-WP-2006-06.

Kaplan, S. (2000). Human nature and environmentally responsible behavior., . Journal of Social Issues 56 (3), 491-508.

Lake, M. (2001, November 8). HOW IT WORKS; A Tale of 2 Engines: How Hybrid Cars Tame Emissions. Retrieved from The New York Times: http://www.nytimes.com/2001/11/08/technology/how-it-works-a-tale-of-2-engines-how-hybrid-cars-tame-emissions.html?scp=1&sq=hybrid%20Toyota%20Prius%201997%20Honda%20Insight%201999&st=cse

Mitchell, J. L. (2010). Toyota won’t admit hiding defects in $US16m settlement with US, In The Australian. Retrieved from http://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/news/toyota-wont-admit-hiding-defects-in-us16m-settlement-with-us/story-e6frg90x

Pelletier, L. G.-D. (1998). Why are you doing things for the environment? The motivation toward the environment scale (MTES)., . Journal of Applied Social Psychology 28 (5), 437-468.

S. Bamberg. (2003). How does environmental concern influence specific environmentally related behaviors? A new answer to an old question. Journal of Environmental Psychology 23 (1),, 21-32.

Shimbun, N. K. (2005).

Stern, P. (2000). Toward a coherent theory of environmentally significant behaviour. . Journal of Social Issues 56,, 407-493.

Teske, J. (2006). The Hybrid Car Market in U.S., Scenario for 2015. Grenoble: MIB-GEM.

Teske, J. C. (2007). Hybrid Vehicles: A Temporary step. International Journal of Automotive Technology and Management, Inderscience, 7 (4), 268-288.

Toyota Australia. (2010, April 16). Retrieved from Toyota Prius: pricing: http://www.toyota.com.au/home

Toyota Is Global Hybrid Leader With Sales Of 7 Million . (2014, October 13). Retrieved from PFR Newswire: http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/toyota-is-global-hybrid-leader-with-sales-of-7-million-279077081.html

V. Griskevicius, J. T. (2010). Going green to be seen: status, reputation, and conspicuous conservation. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 98 (3), , 392-404.